Tuesday, November 10, 2009

Discourse of Inequality part 1

For Part One of Rousseau’s Discourse on Inequality, Rousseau mainly focuses on and, “digs at the roots”, of man’s beginning to show that this beginning has less influence on the social development and the inequality of man than many writers claim. Rousseau examines early man compared to the modern day man of his time. He calls early man “savage man” and modern man “civil man”. Savage man and civil man can be compared to a wild animal and a domestic animal. A house cat is extremely different than a cat in the wild. Savage man is the wild cat and civil man is the domestic. Savage man acts out of instinct. Civil man acts out of free will. According to Rousseau, savage man has no free will. He is no different than an animal. Savage man has all his needs and does not need other human beings. Because of this, nature has done little to bring man together and make him sociable. This was the best time for man since the self- preservation of one did not conflict with the self-preservation of another. Also, pity is evident in all animals, hence evident in savage man, further proving Rousseau’s claim. Rousseau continues his argument by adding that differences in man are from habit and different lifestyles. These aspects of life instituted inequality, not nature. These things were not part of life in the beginning of man since living was much more simple. Man did not need to be social and was not. Once man became sociable, after he developed out of the savage state, then inequality arouse.

3 comments:

Mia Kim said...

James, I like the fact that you mentioned that pity is evident in all animals, hence evident in savage man. Today in class I thought that in reality there are 3 characteristics of man. One is the self preservation which would propel a “war of all against all”. Second one is the natural aversion in which by observing suffering that “war of all against all” does not occur. What then natural aversion of suffering entails is pity. Pity should have been the 3rd characteristic of a man. Rousseau mentions pity on page 38, he says “…pity is a natural sentiment, which by moderating in each individual the activity of the love of oneself, contributes to the mutual preservation of the entire species” Because of the natural, innate sense of pity we “do what is good for ourselves with as little harm as possible to others”. Essentially, pity balances and checks the self-preservation and the natural aversion to the suffering.
-Mia Kim

Unknown said...

In addition to your explanation of how inequality arose amongst natural and modern man, you cannot forget the importance of the development of knowledge. Primarily through technology. After all, the most basic, yet crucial difference between modern and natural man is derived from our technological superiority. Scientific advances and overall knowledge of many things in the world is due to our increased dependency on technology. Rousseau elaborates on this on page 20. He states the savage man's body is the only instrument he knows. However, civilized man, if given time to adapt to the machines around him, he will overcome savage man.

Ladonna Romans said...

Knowledge of tools was also a major turning point in Man's development. Rousseau makes a point that knowledge of tools played a huge role in the socializaion of man. With this new knowledge man was no longer comsumed with the sole task of finding food because tools made that task easier, thus giving him time to develop other faculities.